An illuminative evaluation using descriptive and scientific analysis was undertaken for a graduate degree program in educational technology. Effectiveness of a virtual intervention for primary. An illuminative evaluation on practical art, craft and. The evaluation of capital projects is a key element of a departments financial and service delivery planning, and in the development of the states capital works program. Evaluation is the process of ascertaining the decision of concern, selecting appropriate information, and collecting and analyzing information in order to report summary data useful to decision makers in selecting among alternatives. The pressing need of devoting ourselves to the consideration of the one thing necessary is especially manifest in these days of general chaos and unrest, when so. Parents felt that it was ageappropriate, informative and handled sensitively.
The lessons in this illuminative text are grounded in theory, but made accessible through numerous realworld examplesready for. Section 10 methodological literature guide you need, make use of it, and ignore the rest. This paper discusses some of the techniques that are available for course evaluation, with special reference to illuminative evaluation, illustrated by an evaluation programme undertaken at the university of brunei darussalam. An illuminative evaluation of curricular change at a college of education terence edward dachs a research project submitted to the faculty of education, university of the witwatersrand, in part fulfilment of ths requirements for the degree of master of education. Drawing on illuminative evaluation methods originally developed for use in mainstream education, lorraine ellis describes a new approach to the evaluation of continuing professional education in. This is the first process evaluation of primary school sre. The notion of evaluating policy emerged in its modern form in the 1960s and 1970s and flourishes today in the virtually worldwide adoption of managerialist methods such as public sector management, auditing, and human resource management. An illuminative evaluation of the workplace learning component of unisas diploma in animal health estelle van rensburg student number 8287294 a research report submitted to the school of education, university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg, in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the. Interventiondevelopmentevaluation process perspectives in the classification of evaluation studies types of evaluation from a focus perspective evaluation for programmeintervention planning processmonitoring evaluation. The availability of communitybased research paradigms and an illuminative evaluation technique dinges, trimble, manson, and pasquale provide the researcher with adequate directives to.
Appropriate for upperlevel college courses in education that focus on program evaluation. Pdf illuminative approach in evaluation of curriculum of. Funded articles open access publishing support fund. This research report describes an illuminative evaluation study of the workplace learning component of the diploma in animal. Foundations, principles, and issues addresses the curriculum process and issues that influence it and encourages readers to consider how new thinking impacts curriculum deliberation, development, and implementation. There is increasing interest in quality initiatives that are locally owned and delivered, team based, multiprofessional, and formative. It may also be used by education professionals and decisionmakers who are responsible for implementing new programs and innovations in education. Illuminative evaluation is exploratory in nature and uses both descriptive and interpretive data collection techniques in order to give a multiperspective view through the triangulation of findings chambers, 2004. Clearly, the mode of evaluation that is generally carried out within the context of the systems approach to course or curriculum design illustrated in figure 1 is, by definition, formative evaluation, since the system is never regarded as being perfect or complete. To a historian of ideas, this adjective carries connotations of enlightenment. Illuminative evaluation is an established approach in the social sciences that uses naturalistic qualitative methods to explore the rationale, development, operations, achievements, and difficulties of a particular initiative. Determine the extent to which qualitative methods are appropriate given the evaluations purposes and intended uses. Detailed descriptions of process evaluation are uncommon in the literature but this is vital for identifying issues pertinent to the future rollout and evaluation of programmes.
Be prepared to explain the variations, strengths, and weaknesses of qualitative evaluations. In order to clarify this point of view, we shall first discuss some of the existing. Evaluation criteria course evaluations, student surveys and retention data from previous online program evaluations were used in this study. An illuminative evaluation, andrew topper and sean lancaster. In its simplest form, evaluation as illumination was the outcome of joint collaboration. The study is framed by the theory of illuminative evaluation parlett and. Illuminative evaluation encyclopedia of evaluation search form. Communities of practice are based on the idea that learning involves a group of people exchanging experiences and knowledge. An approach to evaluation that seeks to illuminate the conditions of an educational programme mainly through a qualitative. It is also flexible in responding to a range of contextual constraints. Openended questionnaire, semistructured interviews and. Illuminative evaluation illuminative evaluation refers to what might now be called loosely, and perhaps incorrectly, ethnography. Managing the complexities of judgement in the field.
We use cookies to make interactions with our website easy and meaningful, to better understand the use of our services, and to tailor advertising. Quick training evaluation and feedback form, based on kirkpatrick s learning evaluation model excel file evaluation overview. The illuminative or anthropological, responsive model. Please note that some file types are incompatible with some mobile and tablet. Youll discover the power of storytelling and the way to make data a pivotal point in your story. According to sloan and watson 2001, illuminative evaluation is not a standard methodological package but a general research strategy. Illuminative evaluation, as defined by parlett and hamilton, is not a standard methodological package but a general strategy. To develop an effective sketch of factors those are responsible for the evaluation of curriculum development process. A possible solution is that of illuminative evaluation, a technique which gives evaluation a humanistic rather than a scientific base objective evaluation. How does project evaluation link to strategic plans and the budget process. Responsiveilluminative approach my choice for this duet is grounded in the principles of responsive illuminative evaluation in the broader context of formative evaluation. Action research is a method used for improving practice.
Hamilton, 1976 and productive pedagogies lingard et al. The study used an illuminative evaluation methodology kushner, 2017 and focused on a range of schools in a. The evaluation process is generally not rigidly structured or constrained, and usually gives the evaluator scope to follow up specific areas of interest as and when they become apparent. Zion file system simulator, robert adams and frederic paladin. Experiences from conducting an initial pilot study. This research study used a combination of qualitative and quantitative methodology to provide a comprehensive illuminative evaluation. Illuminative program evaluation model was chosen for this study in terms of its eclectic and processbased characteristics. The discussions vary a good deal in terms of the background knowledge which they assume, so you may need to try.
Illuminative evaluation, art craft and design practical activities, art elements, guidance, practical skills, creativity skills, selfreliance 1. An illuminative evaluation of curricular change at a college of education terence edward dachs a research project submitted to the faculty of education, university of the witwatersrand, in part fulfilment of ths requirements for the. The article is entitled information retrieval for the safety evaluation. Illuminative evaluation is introduced as belonging to a contrasting an thropological research paradigm. Illuminative evaluation of this kind has often been referred to as attempting to open up the black box of the educational process. Evaluating the effectiveness of the teachinglearning process. The empodera project aims to assess the effectiveness of a virtual community of practice aimed at improving primary healthcare professional attitudes to the empowerment of patients with chronic diseases. Methodology, nurse education today on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips.
The second grid, beneath this one, is the same thing with more detail. Pdf illuminative approach in evaluation of curriculum of chinese. Illuminative evaluation for classroom teachers can be an instrument designed to assess a specific. Attempted measurement of educational products gives. This paper gives a description of illuminative evaluation and argues for its use in process. Introduction in botswana, art, craft and design has always been part of the peoples lives. This grid illustrates the basic kirkpatrick structure at a glance. To an english teacher, illuminative may simply be an adjective. Pdf this paper describes the evaluation of curriculum of chinese literature major at bina nusantara university, jakarta, indonesia. Storytelling with data teaches you the fundamentals of data visualization and how to communicate effectively with data. A thorough exploration of the historical, philosophical, psychological, and social context for the field of curriculum, curriculum. Identifying the needs of preservice classroom teachers.
The basic idea is for the investigator to hang out with the participants students, teachers, etc. The study used an illuminative evaluation methodology kushner, 2017 and focused on a range of schools in a large city, selected for their diversity in relation to attainment data psc and reading and socioeconomic status. It seeks to interpret information in order to faciliate remedy of problematic areas. This is an alternative approach from which to study an. The choice of research tactics follows not from research doctrine, but from decisions in each case as to the best available techniques. A s promised in the preface,this books approach is to give you a barebones, nutsandbolts guide about how to do an evaluation. An illuminative evaluation approach incorporating focus groups was used to study the program. To evaluators, however, it has a more specific denotation. An illuminative evaluation is a custom built research strategy which lacks in formal statements of objectives, avoids but does not exclude statistical procedures, employs subjective methods, and is primarily interested in the informing function of an evaluation, rather than the more usual inspectoral or grading. Reginald garrigoulagrange the three ways of the spiritual li. This is due to methodological difficulties and theoretical disagreements in the field. Illuminative evaluation is defined as a form of naturalistic enquiry patton, 1997.
1612 503 865 10 592 1095 641 483 301 360 950 1061 378 172 1451 447 906 1216 1398 692 1405 474 1627 1028 1162 206 980 333 278 575 214 1148 1013 576 1390 714 498 1228 1168 958 252