The behavior model is another way of modeling electromagnetic devices as compared to a finite element model in jmag. More generally, with this fea software one will be able to realize magnetic field analysis, electric field, thermal and structural analysis or cosimulate with circuit software such as saber, psim or matlabsimulink. Comparison charts for structural fea simulation software. Dx studio a suite of tools for simulation and visualization. The first thing that you should be known is what do you want to do with fea and then choose a suitable software for your job. Engineers can use this computeraided engineering cae and computational fluid dynamics cfd software suite to make virtual models of their creations and then subject them to a battery of verification trials. Multifaceted evaluation of various design ideas is made possible by freely. Developed in japan since 1983 it is now used in industries and universities worldwide and is used by all of the top japanese automotive companies for analysis and simulation of electromagnetic devices. Jun 23, 2010 motorsolve im introduction mentor infolytica. Which is the best finite element software for simulation of an incremental sheet metal forming process. Buyers guide for fea software tips to help you select an fea solution. Finite element analysis software fea in the cloud simscale. This is a list of software packages that implement the finite element method for solving partial differential equations. Transient response analysis of embedded type pm motors.
Comparison of main magnetic force computation methods for noise and vibration assessment in. Jmag software offers a magnetic and thermal analysis solutions based on the finite. As a result, it was found that the influence of harmonic iron loss and alternating current copper loss due to the pwm carrier is relatively large. It is distributed in a number of different core packages to cater to specific applications, such as mechanical event simulation and. Jmag rt enables model based development with high concurrency, allowing plant design and control design to be performed concurrently. Wmo114 fea efficiency map compared to measurements. In this paper, we compare the simulationbased efficiency map and the actuallymeasured efficiency map, and analyze the difference between the two efficiency maps and the factors that cause the difference. Comparison of finite element method and modal analysis of violin top plate ye lu music technology area, department of music research schulich school of music mcgill university montreal, canada june 20 a thesis submitted to mcgill university in partial ful llment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in music technology.
Freecad is in itself not a fe software, instead a cad software with integration to fe software. This workshop will focus on the fundamental concepts of electromagnetic design and analysis of electrical machines using jmag fea software. Our ansys license has expired technical support no longer available product purchased outright, and for some reason it doesnt allow the setting of large deflections to be turned on im quite sure this is because we have only the emagelectromagnetic licence. This is the highspeed, highprecision fea software tool at the core of jmag. Other than maxwell, what are the softwares available for electric. Station designed a valve body in solid edge and then captured the geometry with algors incadplus and performed finite element analysis with algor software to ensure that it could withstand high pressures. More generally, with this fea software one will be able to realize magnetic field analysis, electric field, thermal and structural analysis or cosimulate with circuit software.
Finite element analysis consists of a computer model of a material or design that is stressed and analyzed for specific results. Comsol multiphysics a predominantly finite element analysis, solver and simulation software package for various physics and engineering applications, especially coupled phenomena, or multiphysics. In this website you can find side by side comparison chart of 78 finite element analysis. He also explained the importance of fea techniques. Too often we still see companies that trust on simulations being performed with a solidmesh, while the geometry is thin walled, like with sheetmetal, extruded parts or plastic parts. It does not judge power, ease of use, or other userexperience aspects. Technical data sheets can be compared in a single table and can be downloaed in formats compatible with fea programs uch as solidworks, ansys, algor, etc. It is intended for use with microsoft windows and linux operating systems. The table below provides an overview of computeraided design cad software. Matweb uses the term folders for the collection of data sheets specified for comparison or export.
The problems are defined in terms of their variational formulation and can be easily implemented using freefem language. Jmag rt is a system which generates highfidelity plant models jmag rt models in a system level simulation from fea models. Find fea software comparison related suppliers, manufacturers, products and specifications on globalspec a trusted source of fea software comparison information. We also do mechanical engineering, drawing, prototyping and testing, and directly comparisons between test data and jmag fea integrate jmag fea with cad software. Suma was presented with memento by our head of department dr. In selecting a finite element analysis fea software solution, it is crucial that you consider the pre and postprocessor, which can be critical for the analysis speed and accuracy.
If you ask the people why they didnt use a shell mesh, most of the time they will tell you it will take too much time to generate a. Conself browser based cfd and fea simulation platform. Jmag is a comprehensive fea software solution for electromechanical equipment design and development. Realtime simulation of finiteelement analysis permanent magnet synchronous machine drives on a fpga card. In so doing actran provides accurate noise predictions for both the electric motor and the gear reducer. Fpgabased hil simulation of pmsm motor based on high fidelity jmag fea model comparison to low fidelity model. Freefem is a free and opensource parallel fea software for multiphysics simulations.
The motor electromagnetic performance was simulated using the jmag finite element analysis fea software. Finite element analysis software applications are designed to test how objects will respond to external forces. Jmag for inducting heating and multiphysics sub application. Finite element analysis shows whether a product will break, wear out or work the way it was designed. Electromagnetic simulation of rotating machine using jmag fea. Comsol vs ansys i have worked fairly with ansys and i have lots of fea experiences in comsol. Fea software ratingscomparison finite element analysis. Fea analysts rely on the pre and postprocessor to work with an assortment of data files, provide a variety of ways to idealize the model. Simulation software for electromechanical design this is the highspeed, highprecision fea software tool at the core of jmag. Electric machine and magnetic design engineering services, jmag finite element analysis fea software for cae solutions, consulting, many short courses, now building prototype machines. This does not necessarily mean that companies and research institutes save money by adopting fea. A detailed loss table is obtained via fea and added to jmag rt as a csv file. I agree with servando diaz that cosmos is your best friend for starting in fea and its cost is affordable.
Comsol multiphysics finite element analysis software formerly femlab comsol inc. They do, however, get more development for their dollar. For allpurpose 3d programs, see comparison of 3d computer graphics software. Companies and universities use jmag as a tool for product development of electrical components such as motors and actuators, as well as power electronics components. In charge of technical support for jmag, a finite element analysis fea software package for electromechanical analysis and design. Autodesk simulation is a generalpurpose multiphysics finite element analysis software package initially developed by algor incorporated and acquired by autodesk in january 2009. The use of fea tools would typically begin with a quick evaluation using its criticality calculator.
I have compared femm with jmag, ansys emag and ansys maxwell on harmonic analysis of. Ansys is a simulation software product that helps companies ensure their prototypes are free of bugs before they approve them. Therefore, i am of the opinion that it should be removed from this list. It is used in new product design, and existing product refinement. Fpga electric machine library can import in the motor models the inductance and back emf data generated by finite element analysis fea tools. Comparison of main magnetic force computation methods. Electromagnetic field analysis requires the solution of maxwells equations, which necessitates the use of digital computers and an efficient finite element analysis fea software packages like jmag. We perform power density for vehicles as well as wind. A company is able to verify a proposed design will be able to perform to the clients specifications prior to manufacturing or construction. Side by side comparison chart of 78 mechanical finite element analysis fea programs. Comparison of computeraided design software wikipedia.
Analysis of fault conditions in permanentmagnet inwheel. Abaquas is the best software which i have ever seen to analysis the displacement and deformation of different nodes. The purpose of finite element analysis fea software is to reduce the number of prototypes and experiments that have to be run when designing, optimizing, or controlling a device or process. The finite element analysis fea component of simscale enables you to virtually test and predict the behavior of structures and solve complex structural engineering. The fea technique is required when classical dq models cannot be used due to large asymmetry in the motor construction generating nonsinusoidal fluxes and currents.
Finite element analysis fea is a computerised method for predicting how a product reacts to realworld forces, vibration, heat, fluid flow and other physical effects. Fea software ratings comparison corus mechanical 27 feb 03 04. Training on detailed fea analysis for various evaluation of rotating machines. Hands on training with jmag software package for finite element analysis will. In so doing actran provides accurate noise predictions for both the. Sep 05, 2016 a comparison of strain calculation using digital image correlation and finite element software. Jmag is finite element analysis fea software for developing electromechanical equipment. Jmag simulation software for electromechanical equipment. Comparison of main magnetic force computation methods for. Featool multiphysics features the ability to model fully coupled heat transfer, fluid dynamics, chemical engineering, structural mechanics, fluidstructure interaction fsi, electromagnetics, as well as userdefined and custom pde problems in 1d.
He also explained about jmag fea software and about the various scopes and career paths ahead for eee department students. Simscale is a 100% cloudbased simulation software that enables you to test, validate, and optimize your designs through finite element analysis via a standard web browser. In mbd, it is necessary to evaluate devices characteristics without having to wait for the manufacturing of a prototype. Engineers designed the valve to control the flow of gases such as. Element analysis fea software toolset for engineering. Electromagnetic analysis and design methodology for permanent. Syre a matlaboctave code developed to design synchronous reluctance machines with finite element analysis and the aid of multiobjective optimization algorithms. This is a wiki table generated by fea compare project. Which is the best finite element software for simulation of. It also allows you to specify the version of caesar ii file to create. After more than 100 years, most of the easy innovations have already been made to the motors and deriving further performance gains requires finite element. Hardwareintheloop simulation of finiteelement based motor drives with rtlab and jmag.
When buying an fea solution, most users accept the pre and postprocessor that comes with the package. We ran a transient response analysis for one period of electric angle for a largescale 3d pm synchronous motor approx. The table does not include software that is still in development beta software. Developing physical models and prototypes can require a. The main purpose of this software is to convert sensitive caesar ii models from inaccuratewrong ones into a more accurateright ones. Jmag correctly reproduces and visualizes the inductionheating phenomenon that changes intricately, and realizes the optimal design for various purposes using induction heating. I am located in australia working as a mechanical engineer. Featool multiphysics finite element analysis toolbox for multiphysics is a physics, finite element analysis fea, and pde simulation toolbox. Comparison charts for structural fea simulation software finite element analysis fea software helps engineers learn about the structure of their products faster than any prototype. Comparison of finite element method and modal analysis of. I am agree with george, and i am just trying to add some other pros and cons on the subject. But, if you are a multisimulation software using company, standardizing on a common pre and postprocessing platform may result in significant cost savings through common training, user proficiency, and interoperability. This new pm motor software utilizes both finite element fe and analytical.
Preceding unsigned comment added by drejdub talk contribs 12. I think the most important pros of comsol are multiphysics. Breaking the back of multiphysics cae simulation msc software. Reviews from slmti employees about slmti culture, salaries, benefits, worklife balance, management, job security, and more. The user community is requested to submit video recordings using the various fea software packages. Jmag is finite element analysis fea software for developing. Table a free software and b commercial fem software list those that use mostly 2d or 3d fem models. Aug 07, 2017 there are several softwares to conduct fea analysis but to get accuracy you have to use the software depending on your requirement and type of analysis you like to do linear and nonlinear analysis ansys crash analysis pamcrash for good meshing. From system design, to ecu verification using hils, jmag rt has a wide range of uses.
The role of the preprocessor, as seen in figure 2, is to import. During my time with slmti, i learned 3d cad and was starting to use jmag fea software. List of finite element software packages wikipedia. The machine cad is modelled in 2d using the jmag designer software a fea simulation software for electromechanical system designs such as generators, motors, transformers. Fea buyers guide for pre and postprocessing software. Magnetomechanical coupling among software for vibroacoustic em soft struct. Comparison of main magnetic force computation methods for noise. These free fea software comparison can be used for analyzing which software will be perfect for fea analysis. Hardwareintheloop simulation of finiteelement based. For instance, a company could use fea software to test how well a new product design will react to vibration, heat, and fluid flow. Other tables list software specific to the design of motors and inductors. An intuitive interface and precise modeling technology. Motorsolve im introduction mentor infolytica youtube. Which is the best finite element software for simulation.
Which is the best software to conduct fea analysis. Additive manufacturing of soft and hard magnetic materials. Fea softwarecomparison finite element analysis fea. Modifying an existing product or structure is utilized to. A comparison of strain calculation using digital image. Electrical machine design software table below lists all finite element magnetic field software used to design electric machines worldwide. Which is the best fea finite element analysis software. Jmag is software for electromagnetic simulation and design. Jmag is simulation software for the development and design of electrical devices. We primarily design hybrid pm motors and the synchronous generator is 1. Analysis of fault conditions in permanent magnet inwheel motors abstract the use of light inwheel motors is an attractive alternative for smaller passenger vehicles in urban areas. When engineers are performing finite element analysis to visualize the product, it will react to the real world forces like fluid flow, heat, and vibrations, they will be able to use software like finite element analysis software. An inwheel motor design has already been developed in a previous master thesis project. Ben black demonstrates a desktop comparison of jmag finiteelementanalysis fea.
1494 1396 1449 325 1078 1184 949 1132 872 975 414 984 1083 941 714 603 769 1572 1330 411 894 1498 1008 443 101 837 879 622 852 1092 1262 614 887 148